The DC Universe expands its horizons with Clayface, a film that takes its time finding its footing but ultimately delivers a thrillingly grotesque and darkly comedic experience. Director James Watkins crafts a gritty homage to classic revenge thrillers and low-budget horror, drawing inspiration from genre staples like The Fly, Darkman, and Johnny Handsome.
A Tragic Transformation
Based on the DC Comics character, Clayface follows Matt Hagen (Tom Reece Harries), a rising Hollywood star with a troubled past reminiscent of Gotham’s rough neighborhoods. When Hagen’s handsome face is brutally disfigured by henchmen of the city’s most powerful crime lord, he desperately seeks help from Dr. Caitlin Core (Naomi Ackie), a researcher whose cutting-edge nanobot technology has been stolen by her former partners.
Volunteering as a human test subject for her experimental AI-infused regenerative technology, Hagen’s transformation begins promisingly—until it becomes horrifyingly clear that this film isn’t called Clayface because his skincare regimen worked out well.
Sympathetic Monsters
Harries brings a young Malcolm McDowell quality to his performance, balancing impish good looks with hints of inner darkness. He wisely avoids overplaying scenes despite ample opportunities for theatricality. Ackie’s Caitlin emerges as more misguided than mad scientist, sympathetically portrayed even as she bears responsibility for the physical monster Hagen becomes.
The film cleverly suggests that the nanobots haven’t created Hagen’s dark side—they’ve merely unlocked and amplified what was already there. This narrative choice adds depth to his tragic downfall, transforming him from victim to villain in a way that feels both inevitable and unsettling.
Finding Its Groove
Clayface truly comes alive once Hagen stops being a victim and embraces his role as “the gummy angel of death.” Watkins and his creative team make excellent use of Hagen’s shapeshifting abilities, finding both humor and tension as the actor literally inhabits different characters during his revenge spree. These sequences showcase some of the film’s most clever, thrilling, and darkly funny moments.
The movie largely employs old-school practical makeup effects to gruesomely depict Hagen’s transformations, with Harries’ desperate, driven performance selling the illusion of a man becoming a monster. The comics-accurate final form is saved for the closing moments, effectively capping off Hagen’s tragic moral and physical devolution.
A Standalone Story Within the DCU
While carrying the DC Studios banner and set in Gotham City and Coast City, Clayface could easily exist outside the shared universe. Batman isn’t mentioned, though a scene at the Wayne Community Center hints at his presence. Director Watkins explained, “Batman exists in this world, but it’s just not his story. It’s Matt Hagen’s story. It’s a city of several million people, and we’re telling one person’s story within it.”
DC Studios co-CEO Peter Safran addressed how this version of Gotham might influence future projects: “What we’ve always said is that there’s a consistency to the look, but the next filmmaker that tackles Gotham, they use it as a starting point. They can all feel different… Gotham’s not going to become Paris. There’s an elegance to it, a Beaux-Arts brilliance, but Gotham is a little dirty, a little gritty, a little dangerous.”
The Verdict
Clayface proves that the DCU can offer more than superhero fistfights and save-the-world plots. It’s a fun body horror romp that realizes its nasty potential in its final act after a slow-burn setup. While it may carry the DC label, casual filmgoers need no Batman knowledge to enjoy it—they just need the stomach for when things get squeamish.
Rating: A solid entry that rewards patient viewers with gruesome delights
Are you planning to see Clayface opening weekend? Let us know in the comments below!